(Note** This is a poem about a lie spread sixty years ago, that Beatle Paul was dead. This is not, in fact, what happened. Paul McCartney is very much alive today, as of this writing in 2025.)
Paul is dead.
A most beloved Beatle.
I was in junior high school, bussed across town like so many of us then. Against our will. It was a confusing enough time for anybody—never mind a former Mormon girl who knew the church was no longer right for her, but had no idea what might replace it. My parents’ violent drama was coming to a head—if not an end just yet. Of course I had no idea what would take its place. Church, family, blast, boom, bam. Gone.
All my dreams had culminated in this void.
Then The White Album. Second-to-last track: Revolution 9.
Play it backward.
You would hear an otherworldly voice moaning, Turn me on, dead man.
In 1969, this was enough to convince Beatles fans: Paul was dead.
I failed Critical Thinking 101 then. You could hardly blame me, given my upbringing. I was just lost. Instead of considering possibilities—as I might have ten years later—I could only feel despair. The particular existential despair of teenagers.
I remembered The Beatles on Ed Sullivan, singing No Reply.
I tried to telephone, they said you were not home,
that’s a lie, ’cause I know where you’ve been,
I saw you walk in your door.
I nearly died! I nearly died!
Insert at this point, my dad singing, I wish you had! I wish you had!
How he hated his teenage daughter’s adoration of those mop tops. He had been supplanted—though I could not have known it then. A life saver for me, I now realize.
Paul? Dead?
John Hiatt’s lyric lines creep in years later, all jumbled up.
Gone, like the shape I’m in,
gone, like a fifth of gin,
gone, like a Nixon file,
gone, gone away.
Years later, after it was determined to be a hoax, I—and many Beatles lovers like me—still wondered.
And then, sixty years later, I see the similarities.
Feed them lies.
Repeat them often.
Seed them—again and again.
And the masses are left to wonder:
what is real?
What, fiction?





